K-POP / KOREAN CULTURE / REVIEWS

[Review] ‘With All My Heart’, Tohoshinki

Let me tell you, this song is straight up pretty.

Here’s Tohoshinki‘s newest song, ‘With All My Heart‘ for reference:

As if TVXQ’s ‘Best Selection 2010’ including ‘Break Out!’ weren’t enough, they go ahead and throw in this lovely ballad, expressed beautifully through the voices of Junsu, Yunho, Yoochun, Changmin, and Jaejoong.

I’ll go straight into this with the instrumental, because that’s what I’m focusing on in this review.

With All My Heart‘ is stuffed with strings, left and right.  No doubt, an archetype of universal ballads.  If I take this song from section to section, I start getting a little picky.  As a whole, it’s beautiful, but the minor details that bug me are mainly in the actual strings.  Strings, as in plural, is meant to be synonymous with the word ‘orchestra’.  Not a full orchestra, just the particular ensemble made up of string instruments – the main parts: Violin, Viola, Cello, Bass / with the occasional addition of: guitar, harp, etc. – you know.  Well, a lot of mainstream ballads love to zero in on 1/4 of a string ensemble.  Take a wild guess at what section I’m talking about. . .

You know it, the violins.  It’s not that I hate them or anything, but Violin ≠ Orchestra.  If you listen closely, the violins are all you hear in this song, as far as the strings go.  It’s overpowering.  It definitely sounds beautiful, it does wonders to this song, I love it.  But if they had added a little more dimension into the strings, this song could potentially be perfection.

I am 100% in agreement that the higher pitched instruments aught to be used throughout the chorus – in essence, they are the defining melody in a piece of work.  However, going back to this song, if I heard a cello and bass, even a viola section or a lower octave section woven into the verses at the beginning, it would 1.) add weight to the song, and 2.) compliment Tohoshinki’s beautiful vocals.

I guess I’m just a bass whore, cuz I want so much of it.  I really can’t help myself, being a cellist.  That’s my excuse.  If only they had decided on a full orchestra arrangement with some winds and stuff – then I’d definitely shut the hell up.

And as a last complaint, there could have been a few more ‘slides’ here and there, like in the beginning.  A slide, by the way, or glissando is when the musicians literally slide their fingers (technically or not) up or down the fingerboard on the strings.  It’s basically that whine-y sound you hear at the beginning.  Yeah, I’d like more of that, please.

I’ve read comments describing this song as ‘sad’ and people saying they basically ‘cried’ listening to this.  That’s probably more on a sentimental level in connection to their love for the boy band itself (duh).  However, to me, this song sounds a little more romantic in the sense that it has that melancholy overtone in the vocals, meanwhile the instrumental is a little less ominous.  It works.

As for the group’s vocals, which they’ve proven to be exceptional, are pretty much 100% amazing in ‘With All My Heart‘.  Their distinctive harmonizing always puzzles me.  How do they manage to sound like one voice when all of them are singing?  Hell if I know, but they do a nice job at singing in the right tone.

I wont lie, Junsu is my favorite and he killed it here.  His voice alone is enough to satisfy me, but when he spices it up with his graceful vibrato, dude, I die.

I’ve mentioned before that there IS a right way to make a ballad.  Just busting out a slow song doesn’t cut it.  Possessing a quality instrumentation and a graceful rhythm is a must.  Grace is the key word here.  Even heavier rock-ballads are graceful.  FT Island knows what’s up.  So when I hear a ballad come out of the mainstream department, I cross my fingers it isn’t disgusting and empty, such as that dreadful Kelly Clarkson song…what is it, ‘Already Gone‘ ? Yeah, that song sucks hard.

‘With All My Heart’ is meaningful, smooth, and it’s not over the top.  The people behind Tohoshinki know how to produce a good song, decent instrumentation, and wonderful melodies.  Although the strings could have been a little more fuller for me, I’m still satisfied.  All I want is weight in a ballad.  A little extra consideration to the lower strings would’ve gone a long way.

I wonder if they’ll perform it . . .

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “[Review] ‘With All My Heart’, Tohoshinki

  1. I’ve also been puzzled by people’s comments that the song is ‘sad’.
    Rather than that, I think ’emotional’ or ‘moving’ is more appropriate.

    I agree that the song would sound lovely with some more bass – what a beautiful compliment it would be to DBSK’s vocal harmony.

    I wonder though – would adding that bass line take away from the ‘airiness’ of the song? There’s something very light and floaty about the song that is appealing.

    What I’m really looking forward to is hearing the song live. I’m not talking about those performances on Music Japan or Music Fighter were the background music is a track they play over the speakers. I mean like in their concert tours with the musicians playing live music in the background. The difference it made between the studio version of ‘Love in the Ice’ and the concert performance was considerable.

    • That actually crossed my mind after I finished typing this review. I think a fuller orchestration would actually make this song take flight. It would add an elegant sway to it. That’s just me, though. It’s an amazing song by itself, regardless.

      Thanks for stopping by and commenting~! :D

  2. “Their distinctive harmonizing always puzzles me. How do they manage to sound like one voice when all of them are singing? Hell if I know, but they do a nice job at singing in the right tone.”

    Second that, With all my heart had beat Tonight as my 2nd favourite ballad song from TVXQ but still it can’t beat Bolero ;)

  3. Pingback: Kpop Flashback: “Break Out!” by Tohoshinki/Dong Bang Shin Ki | McRoth's Residence

What is your opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s