[Review][Single] J.Y Park Feat. Brown Eyed Girls’s Ga-In – “Someone Else”

written by: drowningn00b

When news hit the interwebs that “Korean Midas” John Young Park, aka JYP, would be making a comeback to the music scene after 3 years since “Sad Freedom,” several thoughts entered my mind, and they were the following:

  1. Why?
  2. Isn’t he still peddling Miss A’s adolescent bodies in negligées?
  3. He’s nowhere near the age of the idols, so who would he feature on his material?
  4. I do like “Honey”, though, even if it is Kim Jo Han’s over sung version from “I Am A Singer”
  5. Wonder Girls’ “So Hot” wasn’t bad either.

Clearly I was conflicted. JYP is at that age where he’s an ajossi, and in the negative connotation. He can’t perform songs about falling in love with the girls of Miss A, or falling out of love with the guys from 2AM. He’s been through a relationship, a marriage, then a divorce, and as a single man, his onstage persona cannot include teenagers. But I am a fan of the man’s work. When he does it right, it’s awesome. So how would this work, exactly – this comeback of his? A glimpse of this came with his collaboration with YG loverboy, SE7EN, for the song “When I Can’t Sing”, and now he’s back with “Someone Else” with Brown Eyed Girls’ Ga-In. Baby-faced though she is, Ga-In is an adult, so any possible pedo references can be thrown aside. Now onto the song.

I was surprised! I thought this style of R&B had left the mainstream years ago and only exists now in hip-hop love songs. Clearly JYP loves this style, because “Someone Else” is a throwback R&B ballad that’s easily translated to a live performance. The bass line is fantastic, intensifying the drum beat and bringing the song somewhere between a ballad and a mid-tempo track. JYP’s voice isn’t the best out there, but his style on this song brings the right amount of longing and urging. For someone who hasn’t performed in years, the level of control in his voice is pretty good. As the female perspective, Ga-In was the perfect choice. The last time I heard her deliciously deep register was a year and half ago on her solo debut, “Irreversible”, and more distinctly several years before that, on Brown Eyed Girls’ “Tagger” ballad. Ga-In’s delivery doesn’t rise to harmonize alongside JYP’s higher register, but allowed to float along without restraint. If there’s one thing JYP deserves credit is his handling of voices to sound right, and he brought that touch to “Someone Else”.


I fell for this song on first listen. JYP has a knack for this style of R&B and I’m glad he stuck to his guns for “Someone Else”. He has a propensity for stubbornness in that approach (see all the JYP-produced tracks for Wonder Girls), but it works here because no one is doing that right now. The nostalgic throwback style of “Someone Else”, the contrast between JYP and Ga-In, and the simplicity in the production is a good primer for what to expect from the legendary producer for his upcoming release. But to quote RuPaul, “…and don’t f&^k it up.”


9 thoughts on “[Review][Single] J.Y Park Feat. Brown Eyed Girls’s Ga-In – “Someone Else”

  1. Agree with everything you said except this: “If there’s one thing JYP deserves credit [for, it] is his handling of voices to sound right…”

    I would give him credit for it, but he’s so hit or miss in this aspect of his music. Have we so quickly forgotten Miss A’s “Touch” a.k.a. “Ow My Ears”? And let’s be real – Se7en sounded awful in “When I Can’t Sing”. I think he’s good about handling voices that already have their own character (e.g. his own, Ga-in’s, Ye-eun and Sunye) but with other singers he basically just has them follow his lead, which isn’t always the best approach.

  2. Pingback: [Review][Album] J.Y. Park – “Spring: 5 Songs for a New Love” « McRoth's Residence

  3. Pingback: Month In KPOP – April « McRoth's Residence

What is your opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s